PLAYBOOK VS SHADE

Every Seat Adds Up. Do the Math Before You Pick.

How Playbook and Shade compare for videos and images, and where Recharm fits.

Start 14 days free trial

Playbook vs Shade at a Glance

Both give teams a shared library with approvals and sharing. The main difference is visual boards for creative teams with Playbook, and a cloud drive that mounts like a local one with Shade.

  • Playbook turns stored files into web pages with its Publish sites feature.
  • Shade adds timestamped and range-based comments, with approval status tracked in metadata.
  • Recharm is $299 a month with unlimited users, and cuts videos into clips you can tag and search with AI. Search and clips are in preview.

Playbook vs Shade Comparison Table

CriterionPlaybookShadeRecharm
Core File and Video Management
Purpose-built for ad creative organizationNot offeredNot offeredOffered
Store and manage video filesOfferedOfferedOffered
Create modular video clipsNot publishedNot publishedOffered, preview feature
Categorize videos by sceneNot publishedNot publishedOffered, preview feature
Categorize images by themeOffered on a higher-tier plan onlyOfferedOffered, preview feature on a higher-tier plan or paid add-on
Auto-sync with Google Drive, Dropbox and Frame.ioNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Search and Discovery
Keyword and metadata searchOfferedOfferedOffered
Transcript search (find by spoken words)Offered on a higher-tier plan onlyOfferedOffered
AI visual search in imagesOffered on a higher-tier plan onlyOfferedOffered, preview feature on a higher-tier plan or paid add-on
AI visual search in video (find by appearance, objects, scenes)Not publishedOfferedOffered, preview feature
Search at the clip level inside a videoNot publishedNot publishedOffered, preview feature
Organization and Collaboration
Tags, metadata and duplicate detectionOfferedOfferedOffered
Collections and boards for grouping assetsOfferedOfferedOffered
Deep links to specific clips or momentsNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Usage rights trackingNot publishedNot publishedOffered on the Managed plan
Commenting and feedback on assetsOfferedOfferedComing soon
Review and approval workflowsOfferedOfferedNot offered
Shareable links for assetsOfferedOfferedOffered
Branded portals for teams and partnersNot publishedOfferedNot offered
Brand guidelines hubNot publishedNot publishedNot offered
Integrations with creative tools and CMSOfferedOfferedOffered
Creative Analytics
Ad performance metrics next to the creativeNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Asset usage and engagement reportingNot publishedNot publishedNot published
Built for Ads and Claude
Ad-specific tags (angle, persona, problem, emotion)Not publishedNot publishedOffered
Creative briefsNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Connects to Claude (plugin or MCP server)Offered on a higher-tier plan onlyOfferedOffered
Claude builds creative briefs from your libraryNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Claude makes ads and videos from your libraryNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Managed Services
Done-for-you tagging by creator and productNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Custom A-roll and B-roll splicingNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Re-organization as needs evolveNot publishedNot publishedOffered
Governance and Security
Role-based access and permissionsNot publishedOfferedOffered
Single sign-onOffered on a higher-tier plan onlyOffered on a higher-tier plan onlyNot published
Published security certificationsNot publishedOfferedNot published
Pricing and Setup
Published pricingOfferedOfferedOffered
No per-seat pricingNot offeredNot offeredOffered
Free trialOfferedOfferedOffered
  • Offered
  • Not offered
  • Not published on the vendor's site
  • Preview feature
  • Managed plan
  • Higher-tier plan or paid add-on only
  • Coming soon

Videos and Images Deserve a DAM of Their Own. Meet Recharm.

Recharm is a video-first asset library built to find the right clip fast.

  • AI taggingTag videos automatically, and sort images with the AI image add-on (preview)
  • AI visual searchFind footage by what's in the frame (preview)
  • Clip cuttingCut videos into clips to find the exact moment (preview)
  • Claude pluginTurn your library into creative briefs and videos with Claude
ILIA Beauty12 clips

Clips and tags from Recharm's demo library of ILIA Beauty creator videos.

Start 14 days free trial

Frequently Asked Questions

What are Playbook and Shade each built for?

Playbook focuses on visual boards for creative teams, and Shade on a cloud drive that mounts like a local one. Recharm puts video first, with AI tags and clips that point to the exact moment (search and clips in preview).

How do Playbook and Shade handle video?

Both handle video. Playbook has timecoded video comments, and Shade has timestamped comments and AI search across transcripts and faces. Recharm adds clip cutting, so you can search for the exact moment (in preview).

Do Playbook and Shade offer approval workflows?

Yes, both do. Playbook lists review and approval as a core feature. Shade pairs timestamped review with approval status in metadata. Recharm has no approval workflow, so teams track approvals outside the library.

Do Playbook and Shade connect to Claude and AI tools?

Both do. Playbook has MCP on Pro and above. Shade lists an MCP server. Recharm also has a Claude plugin that builds creative briefs and videos from your library.

Do Playbook, Shade and Recharm offer a free trial?

Playbook has a free plan with no card. Shade has a free trial on Growth. Recharm offers a 14-day free trial.

Start with Your Own Footage

Import a folder of raw footage and see the difference clip-level search makes.

Start 14 days free trial

or explore Recharm’s features and pricing